Home - Chinalogue - Who Sank the Cheonan? Part 2

Who Sank the Cheonan? Part 2

Jun 14, 2010

Susan Osman invites Yoichi Shimatsu, former editor of The Japan Times, and Prof. Chung Kiyul from Tsinghua University, to discuss bigger pictures surrounding The Cheonan incident.

Tags: South Korean naval vessel,cause,North Korea,Cheonan

TEXT COMMENTS(0)

WRITE A COMMENT(maximum 1000 words)

ALL PROGRAMS

[2011/03/07] Chinalogue: Science Awareness in China
[2011/03/07] Chinalogue: China’s Migrant Workers
[2011/03/02] Chinalogue: Ambassador Huntsman in the Running For 2012?
[2011/02/28] Chinalogue: China Moves Toward Cleaner Energy
[2011/02/28] Chinalogue: China's Role In Africa's Security
[2011/02/21] Chinalogue: The Innovation Race
[2011/02/16] Chinalogue: Charities Operating in China
[2011/02/16] Chinalogue: Are Chinese Mothers Superior?
[2011/02/10] Chinalogue: China's Health Care Reform
[2011/02/10] Chinalogue: Hooked Up And Disconnected
[2011/01/23] Chinalogue: China's Media Image Following U.S. Visit
[2011/01/22] Chinalogue: Hu and Obama Making History
[2011/01/22] Chinalogue: Nuclear Club Fallout
[2011/01/18] Chinalogue: President Hu Visits The White House
[2011/01/06] 2011 Economic Outlook
[2011/01/05] Sparring On The Korean Peninsula
[2010/12/30] 2010 News Roundup
[2010/12/20] Exposing Secrets: Wikileaks
[2010/12/10] Development Of Charities In China
[2010/12/04] China's Sports Industry
[2010/12/03] Internet Empires
[2010/12/03] Finding A Home For China's Orphans
[2010/11/29] PR Cyber Spin And Smear Campaigns
[2010/11/12] China's Gome Company: Battle For Ownership
[2010/11/12] Currency War: Rmb Appreciation
[2010/11/12] Miscarriage Of Justice
[2010/11/12] The State Of Asian Sport
[2010/11/12] China's Sports Industry
[2010/11/09] Art And Media In China Part 2
[2010/11/05] Family-run Businesses In China
[2010/11/01] China As A Target In U.S. Midterm Elections
[2010/10/26] Writer Interview: Deborah Fallows
[2010/10/13] Fishing Boat Collision, Diaoyu Islands Part 2
[2010/10/09] The 2nd Sino-American Financial Talents Forum
[2010/10/03] China's Agricultual Industry Part 2
[2010/09/30] China's Agricultual Industry Part 1
[2010/09/26] Real Estate in China
[2010/09/25] Traffic Problems and China's Car Industry Pt I
[2010/09/25] Traffic Problems and China's Car Industry Pt 2
[2010/09/17] Fishing Boat Collision, Diaoyu Islands Part 1
[2010/09/06] Military Issues in Asia Part 1
[2010/09/06] Military Issues in Asia Part 2
[2010/09/06] Philippines Hostage Crisis Part 1
[2010/09/06] The U.S. Role in Iraq and Afghanistan Part 1
[2010/09/06] Sidney's Incredible Journey in China Part 1
[2010/09/06] Sidney's Incredible Journey in China Part 2
[2010/09/06] Oil Spills: Dalian & The Gulf of Mexico Part 1
[2010/09/06] Oil Spills: Dalian & The Gulf of Mexico Part 2
[2010/08/27] Natural and Man-made Disasters
[2010/08/18] Writer Interview: Rowan Simons
[2010/08/09] International Music Academy Part 1
[2010/08/09] International Music Academy Part 2
[2010/07/29] Writer Interview: Jeffrey Wasserstrom
[2010/07/21] China-Africa Relations Part 1
[2010/07/21] China-Africa Relations Part 2
[2010/07/06] Sex and Chinese Cities Part 1
[2010/07/06] Sex and Chinese Cities Part 2
[2010/07/05] Social Instability in China Part 1
[2010/07/05] Social Instability in China Part 2
[2010/07/04] Great Wall Revisited Part 1
[2010/07/04] Great Wall Revisited Part 2
[2010/07/04] Classical Music In China Part 1
[2010/07/04] Classical Music In China Part 2
[2010/07/03] Writer Interview: Catherine Sampson
[2010/06/29] Environmental Education in China Part 1
[2010/06/29] Environmental Education in China Part 2
[2010/06/29] Chinese Literature Going Abroad Part 1
[2010/06/29] Chinese Literature Going Abroad Part 2
[2010/06/14] China's Labor Conditions Part 1
[2010/06/14] China's Labor Conditions Part 2
[2010/06/14] Who Sank the Cheonan? Part 1
[2010/06/14] Who Sank the Cheonan? Part 2
[2010/06/14] Revaluing China's Currency Part 1
[2010/06/14] Revaluing China's Currency Part 2
[2010/06/14] Life in China in the 1960's and 1970's Part 1
[2010/06/14] Life in China in the 1960's and 1970's Part 2
[2010/03/22] Homosexuality in China Part 2
[2010/03/21] Homosexuality in China Part 1
[2010/03/17] Green Buildings Part 2
[2010/03/17] Green Buildings Part 1
[2010/02/25] Study Pressures for kids in China Part 2
[2010/02/25] Study Pressures for kids in China Part 1
[2010/02/13] Top 10 Myths About China In 2009 Part 2
[2010/02/13] Top 10 Myths About China In 2009 Part 1
[2010/02/11] Death Penalty in China Part 2
[2010/02/11] Death Penalty in China Part 1
[2010/02/10] Education Initiative in China Part 2
[2010/02/10] Education Initiative in China Part 1
[2010/02/04] Photography in China Part 2
[2010/02/04] Photography in China Part 1
[2010/01/30] Real Estate Bubble in China? Part 2
[2010/01/29] Real Estate Bubble in China? Part 1
[2010/01/25] China: 20 Years in Retrospect Part 2
[2010/01/24] China: 20 Years in Retrospect Part 1
[2009/12/30] Independent Movies In China part 1
[2009/12/30] Independent Movies In China part 2
[2009/12/28] American musician in China Part 2
[2009/12/27] American musician in China Part 1
[2009/12/26] Renowned Beijing Opera Performer Part 2
[2009/12/26] Government Public Relations Part 2
[2009/12/25] Renowned Beijing Opera Performer Part 1
[2009/12/25] Government Public Relations Part 1
[2009/12/25] The image of "Made in China" Part 2
[2009/12/24] The image of "Made in China" Part 1
[2009/12/17] Hua Dan: An NGO In China Part 2
[2009/12/16] Hua Dan: An NGO In China Part 1
[2009/12/08] Fighting HIV/AIDS in China Part 2
[2009/12/07] Fighting HIV/AIDS in China Part 1
[2009/12/04] Chinalogue - Vision for Copenhagen Part 2
[2009/12/03] Chinalogue - Vision for Copenhagen Part 1
[2009/12/01] Chinalogue - Chinese Soft Power Part 2
[2009/12/01] Chinalogue - Chinese Soft Power Part 1
[2009/11/30] Media coverage on Obama's visit Part 2
[2009/11/30] Media coverage on Obama's visit Part 1
[2009/11/22] Analysis of Obama's trip to China Part 2
[2009/11/21] Analysis of Obama's trip to China Part 1
[2009/11/16] Chinalogue - Translation & Dubbing Part 1
[2009/11/16] Chinalogue - Translation & Dubbing Part 2
[2009/11/14] Obama's first visit to China Part 2
[2009/11/13] Obama's first visit to China Part 1
[2009/11/10] Underground Music in China Part 2
[2009/11/09] Underground Music in China Part 1
[2009/11/02] Design and innovation Part 2
[2009/11/01] Design and innovation Part 1
[2009/10/28] Learning Chinese in China Part 2
[2009/10/27] Learning Chinese in China Part 1
[2009/10/26] Tim Yip: Oscar-winning Art Director Part 2
[2009/10/25] Tim Yip: Oscar-winning Art Director Part 1
[2009/10/24] English Blogs about China Part 2
[2009/10/23] English Blogs about China Part 1
[2009/10/20] Buddhism in China Part 2
[2009/10/19] Buddhism in China Part 1
[2009/10/17] Architecture in Beijing Part 1
[2009/10/17] Architecture in Beijing Part 2
[2009/10/03] 60th Anniversary of the PRC Part 2
[2009/10/03] 60th Anniversary of the PRC Part 1
[2009/10/01] Chinalogue- Mental health Part 2
[2009/09/30] Chinalogue- Mental health Part 1
[2009/09/29] Nature Conservation Part 2
[2009/09/28] Nature Conservation Part 1
[2009/09/24] Chinese Craze for Learning English 2
[2009/09/23] Traditional Chinese Music Part 2
[2009/09/23] Chinese Craze for Learning English 1
[2009/09/22] Traditional Chinese Music Part 1
[2009/09/21] Chinalogue - Chinese Manners Part 2
[2009/09/20] The Australian Ambassador to China Part 2
[2009/09/20] Chinalogue - Chinese Manners Part 1
[2009/09/19] The Australian Ambassador to China Part 1
[2009/09/16] Chinalogue - Chinese Art and Media Part 1
[2009/09/16] Chinalogue - Chinese Art and Media Part 1
[2009/09/14] Chinalogue - 798 & Chinese Modern Art 1
[2009/09/14] Chinalogue - 798 & Chinese Modern Art 2
[2009/09/11] Chinalogue - Chinese Food Part 2
[2009/09/09] Chinalogue - Chinese Food Part 1
[2009/08/22] Chinalogue - Beijing Improvization Part 2
[2009/08/21] Chinalogue - Beijing Improvization Part 1
[2009/08/19] Chinalogue - The Internet Part 2
[2009/08/17] Chinalogue - The Internet Part 1
[2009/08/12] Chinalogue - Foreign Magicians in China Part 2
[2009/08/10] Chinalogue - Foreign Magicians in China Part 1
[2009/08/06] Chinalogue - Women's Status Part 2
[2009/08/05] Chinalogue - Women's Status Part 1
[2009/08/02] Chinalogue - Resurgence of Confucianism Part 2
[2009/08/01] Chinalogue - Resurgence of Confucianism Part 1

RELATED PROGRAMS

Who Sank the Cheonan? Part 1

Susan Osman invites Yoichi Shimatsu, former editor of The Japan Times, and Prof. Chung Kiyul from Tsinghua University, to discuss bigger pictures surrounding The Cheonan incident.
Views On US Military Exercises

U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates is in South Korea this week to show unity between the two countries and to plan joint-military drills meant to-- as one U.S. military official put it-- send a message of deterrence to North Korea. This comes four months after the sinking of a South Korean warship- the Cheonan- which killed 46 soldiers. The United Nations condemned the attack, but did not go as far as laying blame on North Korea. An international investigation led by south Korea concluded it was sunk by a North Korean torpedo, which North Korea denies.
Military Exercise Sparks Anger

China says it is concerned about reports that a U.S. aircraft carrier may join a military exercise with South Korea amid a tense standoff with North Korea over the sinking of a warship from the South.

The South Korean corvette the Cheonan was sunk off the peninsula's west coast in March, killing 46 sailors. South Korea has blamed the North for sinking the Cheonan with a torpedo fired from a submarine, a charge the North denies.

The United States and South Korea have since said they will hold a joint anti-submarine drill.
China's Foreign Policy Thinking

This week's big joint US-South Korean naval exercises in the Sea of Japan have made China uneasy because of their geographical proximity to the mainland. The manoeuvres involve an aircraft carrier and 200 aircraft, and are being staged in response to the sinking of a South Korean warship in March. South Korea and the US believe North Korea torpedoed the Cheonan warship and say their joint naval drill is intended to deter North Korea from undertaking military action against the South.
Korean Warship Mystery

What caused the sinking of a South Korean naval vessel in the Yellow Sea on March 26 is not in doubt: a huge explosion tore through the frigate sending it to the bottom and killing 46 of the 104 sailors on board. But what is not yet known is the cause of that explosion, and whether it was an accident - or something more sinister.

Seoul has not yet directly blamed North Korea for the sinking and Pyongyang has denied any involvement. However South Korea's defense minister has quoted investigators who say a torpedo may have caused the blast. The investigation is expected to conclude this week.
North Korea Tensions

Tensions on the pided Korean peninsula have risen dramatically since international investigators said last week that North Korea was responsible for a torpedo attack on a South Korean warship in March that killed 46 sailors.
Relations are now at their lowest point in a decade. South Korea, backed by the U.S., Japan and other allies, began implementing a package of punitive measures earlier this week - ranging from slashing trade, resuming propaganda warfare and barring the North's cargo ships. Those were seen as among the strongest it could implement short of military action. Washington has promised ''unequivoca'' military support for South Korea.

North Korea meanwhile has vowed to retaliate. It has threatened all out war, cut relations with South Korea and has barred South Korean ships and airliners from passing through its territory.
China, North Korea's main ally, has so far tried to remain neutral, calling on both sides to ''exercise restraint.'' Whether or not the two sides hold off, or launch into a cross-border war is a question that's on a lot of people's minds at the moment. And it's one that's being debated online here. Let's cross to the newsroom now where our researcher Emma Wang has been gauging reaction.
Sparring On The Korean Peninsula

The world is on edge after North Korea shelled South Korea off disputed waters. Susan Osman's guests get heated over the historic significance and how the international community should get involved.

Aired December 3, 2010
Hillary Clinton Visit

US secretary of State Hillary Clinton is currently in Beijing heading a 200-strong delegation to discuss a range of both strategic and economic issues with Chinese officials, particularly the value of the Chinese currency, the RMB, compared to the dollar and disagreements over tariffs and market access.

But the talks have been overshadowed by events on and off the Korean peninsula. Following the results of an a international investigation into the sinking of a South Korean, which claims Nor Korea was responsible, Clinton has had strong words for Pyongyang
And the fact that she travels to the South Korean capital Seolu from Beijing have added urgency to her efforts to garner some support from the Chinese Government, which is seen as the country which holds most sway over North Korea.

But while heads of government and their officials at various levels negotiate and posture, what would ordinary Chinese people like to ask the US secretary of State if they had the chance? Well that's what we asked on the streets of Beijing this week. Here's what they had to say in today's Straight from the Street